Much of What You Hear About Forest Management is Wrong

– An excellent summary of the propaganda we face from the habitat clearance industry –

The following article by our friend George Wuerthner takes on the typical fallacies promoted by forest industry representatives (and unfortunately many fire researchers and managers) about the need for “active management” in forests. The article originally appeared in Oregon’s News Register.


Last week’s commentary by Chris Edwards and Travis Joseph, “Active management key to protecting our forests,” (in the News Register) was typical of forest industry representatives. Their commentary fails to see the forest through the trees.

First, they state that 2.5 million acres burned in Oregon, but neglect to note the vast majority of that acreage was grassland or shrubland, not forested at all. Several big rangeland fires, including the 578,000-acre Big Grass Fire that charred Eastern Oregon, accounted for most of the acreage burned.

In fact, non-forested acreage accounts for most of the acreage burned annually across the West. But the timber industry includes those acreages to inflate the number and argue for more logging of our forests.

Industry representatives argue that more active management is needed (i.e., logging), neglecting to note that actively managed private timberland actually burns at a higher severity than unmanaged lands.

A study by OSU forestry professors documented, “Management and forest age were really important, but oddly enough, how much biomass was there before the fire was not important.” They found that private timberlands burned 30 percent more severely than public lands.

Another study reviewing more than 1,500 wildfires found that areas with the highest protection (i.e., no logging), like wilderness and parks, burned at lower severity than lands under active management. The authors concluded: “We found forests with higher levels of protection had lower severity values even though they are generally identified as having the highest overall levels of biomass and fuel loading.”

Next, they suggest that national forests are “overstocked.” Again, this focus on forest density and biomass fails to note that the thinned forests under “active management” burn at high severity.

This is due to several factors.

The necessary ingredients for a high-severity blaze are extreme drought, low humidity, high temperature and wind. Dense forests have lower temperatures, higher humidity, and less wind penetration than open thinned forests. Thus, in many fires, the least-burned tree pockets tend to be in the densest forests.

Common sense confirms this. Oregon’s densest forests and highest biomass are located along the coast. Yet these forests seldom burn except under extremely unusual circumstances.

In the last century, from the late 1930s through the 1980s, we saw fewer ignitions and less acreage burned. Why?

It had nothing to do with forestry or “fire suppression. The climate was cool and moist.

Glaciers were growing on all of Oregon’s highest peaks. Scientists were predicting we were entering another Ice Age.

What happens when you have cool, moist conditions? You get fewer ignitions, and the fires that do start self-extinguish or are easy to control. You also get greater seedling survival, which leads to greater tree density.

Beginning in the late 1980s, rising CO2 emissions shifted the climate toward drier, warmer conditions with major drought. Across the West, we are experiencing some of the worst drought conditions in more than a thousand years.

And as advocates for the timber industry, Edwards and Joseph neglected to mention that the wood products industry is Oregon’s largest single source of CO2 emissions.

I won’t go into the ecological value of the tree snags and down wood that result from high-severity blazes, but these elements are critical to forest ecosystems.

If you’re concerned about wildfire threats to homes, there are better alternatives than logging in the forest. For starters, stop building homes in the Wildland-Urban Interface.

You can also reduce home flammability through home hardening. This has proven far more effective at protecting homes and communities than logging the forest.

Dr. Jack Cohen, a researcher who made a career of examining home losses due to wildfire, noted you can’t eliminate wildfire, but that doesn’t mean your home must burn.


About the writer: Bend resident George Wuerthner, executive director of Public Lands Media, is an ecologist who has studied wildfire for decades. He has published several books on the subject, including Wildfire: A Century of Failed Forest Policy. He has hiked and studied wildlands throughout the West, but has made Greater Yellowstone an area of particular focus.

George Wuerthner in the chaparral.

Leave a Reply