Cal Fire Needs to Think Outside the Box, But Can They?

Dear Governor Newsom,

The safety of our families and communities depends on your leadership.

You have an opportunity to be the first governor to inspire a successful wildfire policy based on science, not one dependent on a bygone era – an era during which we did not have to confront the challenges of climate change and an increasing population living near wildland areas.

However, Cal Fire will resist. They will say we need to take a “dual” approach in addressing wildfire – clear habitat and log now, then figure out a plan to harden homes against fire. What they mean is that they want to do more of what they have always done. This is the same approach that has failed to address the actual cause of loss of life and property since the 2003 Cedar Fire.

Cal Fire is in the fire suppression business, not the fire safe community business. As a result, they emphasize the misguided notion that they can control Nature by clearing habitat or logging forests far from where most Californians are at risk. Meanwhile, thousands of homes burn and lives are lost during wind-driven wildfires that ignite our communities miles ahead of the fire front, fires that Cal Fire will never be able to control.

We need to focus on making our communities fire safe now. The science is clear on this point. Communities have already proven that fire safe retrofits can be efficiently and quickly installed. The decision is not as complicated as some claim, it just requires the courage to question the status quo.

Every dollar spent logging forests far from where the majority of people at risk live and continuing what Cal Fire has always done, is a dollar less for fire safe communities. Such an approach will not only fail to protect the majority of Californians from wildfire, fail to meet our carbon sequestration goals, and fail to protect vital natural resources, but will in many cases make the landscape more flammable.

Cal Fire will say that their fuel treatment projects will allow them to control 95% of the fires they confront. This is equivalent to only preparing for the 95th percentile of earthquakes, or what we would feel as a result of a magnitude 2.5. Until Cal Fire starts addressing the fires that cause nearly all the destruction, the wind-driven fires that ignore fuel treatments and defensible space, communities will continue to be lost.

The only way to address those wind-driven fires is to direct Cal Fire to think outside the box and start accepting the fact that we are facing a home ignition problem, not a fire suppression problem.

 The first step in that direction would be to reject the current approach Cal Fire and the California Board of Forestry is taking with their proposed Vegetation Treatment Program. We urge you to study the 24 recommendations we have provided in our analysis of the program at the link below.

Please, for our families and communities, take the courageous step and question Cal Fire’s outdated paradigm.

The California Chaparral Institute


Our analysis of Cal Fire’s/Board of Forestry’s proposed Vegetation Treatment Program.

An example of a scientifically sound Fire Management Plan EIR from the Santa Monica Mountains National Recreation Area, National Park Service

Coffey I banner b
Coffey Park, Santa Rosa, CA, after the 2017 Tubbs Fire.

One Comment on “Cal Fire Needs to Think Outside the Box, But Can They?

  1. “Cal Fire will say that their fuel treatment projects will allow them to control 95% of the fires they confront.”

    Where’s the EVIDENCE? Where are the CALCULATIONS? Where are the EXAMPLES?

    What is percentage of the fires they “confront” do they control NOW?

    What constitutes “control?”

    Compare the WEATHER CONDITIONS of the fires they cannot control now with those present in those which they DO control NOW.

    Read the book, “Lies, Damn Lies, and Statistics.”

    Number games are no substitute for REALITY and DETAIL!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: